Monday, June 14, 2004

Medical Malpractice battle gets personal

Medical-malpractice battle gets personal Some doctors refuse to treat attorneys
By Laura Parker

There are 73,084 working lawyers in Texas. Selina Leewright never thought that being married to one would cost her her job.

But that's why Leewright, a nurse, was fired last summer by Good Shepherd Medical Center in the East Texas city of Longview. In dismissing her, hospital officials praised her nursing skills as ''fantastic.'' But they told her that because her husband, Marty, worked at a law firm that does medical-malpractice litigation, the hospital could not continue to employ her. ''I was dumbfounded,'' Leewright says. ''They just assumed that my husband does medical malpractice, which he doesn't at all.''

Leewright's firing was a measure of how toxic the battle over medical-malpractice lawsuits has become. Hospital administrators and doctors across the nation, furious over what they see as waves of frivolous lawsuits that have driven up malpractice insurance costs, are striking back against lawyers with hardball tactics that, in some cases, are raising ethical questions.

Some doctors are refusing medical treatment to lawyers, their families and their employees except in emergencies. Professional medical societies are trying to silence their peers by discouraging doctors from testifying as expert witnesses on behalf of plaintiffs. And a New Jersey doctor who supported malpractice legislation that his colleagues opposed was ousted from his hospital post.

While sharing their peers' anger over malpractice lawsuits, some doctors see such tactics -- particularly the refusal of treatment -- as contrary to the Hippocratic oath, in which new doctors acknowledge ''special obligations to all my fellow human beings.''

But Chris Hawk, a surgeon in Charleston, S.C., says the notion of refusing treatment to malpractice lawyers, their family members and associates not only is justified, it's necessary. ''This idea may be repulsive,'' Hawk says. ''It's hardball. But it's ethical.''

Hawk, 57, says that a doctor's ethical obligation to treat patients applies only to emergency care. ''Physicians are not bound to treat everybody who walks through their door,'' he says.

Doctors and lawyers long have been at odds over malpractice litigation. But soaring malpractice-insurance premiums, which hit doctors in high-risk specialties such as neurosurgery and obstetrics particularly hard, have fueled the debate. For doctors who blame the increases in their premiums on unwarranted lawsuits and large jury awards, the solution is clear: Overhaul the nation's civil-litigation system, starting with limits on what jurors can award in damages.

Malpractice lawyers, led by the Association of Trial Lawyers of America, counter that rising premiums have more to do with the insurance industry than jury awards. They say tighter regulation of the industry is needed.

The lawyers say that stifling malpractice litigation could deny Americans some of their rights to seek redress in court when doctors make mistakes.


Anonymous Anonymous said...

Emu Boots sale approximately 50%, and if you pay for two main couples of
uk ugg boots, many surplus treats will likely be offered.
If you've got no idea about whether a pair of boots you want are real or otherwise, it is advisable not to get them. So you can find that shoes, clothes, even bags for kids has be exquisite than before.

Also visit my webpage :: prada

3:08 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

There are various online auction sites that you simply can check
out from time to time if you wanted to get the best prices on your uggs.

And recollection, they may eventually be willful Worn tedium without situation, so the graduate are able to do their job.
Delicately wipe it by using a damp material, will not likely brush it
fiercely that carries a brush, don't melt away the sneakers with boiled water, and use washing detergent and alkaline cleaning fluid to scrub it on the same time.

my page: プラダ バッグ

2:32 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Just as the name implies, these ugg boots are from Australia,
which are crafted from twin-tier merino wool. When it comes to
probably the most styling infant, dress your toddler in uggs.
Nevertheless, with super delicate ease and
convenience, increased desire, and winter season season approaching, you are able to still discover some very nice provides.

Check out my website - prada

10:30 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Cheap Burberry Handbags These furnishings are a good choice.
If you might have no idea about whether boots you want are
real or otherwise, it is advisable not to purchase
them. Nevertheless, with super delicate ease
and convenience, increased desire, and winter weather season approaching, you'll be able to still discover some great provides.

My web page: プラダ バッグ

11:02 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Just since the name implies, these ugg boot are from Australia, which can be crafted
from twin-tier merino wool. If you might have no idea about whether boots you want
are real or otherwise, it's advisable not to buy them. The unique qualities in the sheepskin mean they will keep your feet warm in even the coldest of weather, but that if you use them in summer they will not overheat your foot.

Also visit my weblog: prada

11:40 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

If you disregarded the Ugg guidelines and wore your
boots in water, otherwise you dropped liquid in your boot, you may have stains along
your boots. These types of Ugg Boots Clearance may be found in 2 colors from the store at
fine sand as well as saying. So you will get that shoes, clothes, even bags for children
has are more exquisite than before.

my webpage -

1:28 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Many celebrities have been fascinated using the
retro looks of these boots, for example, Oprah, Paris Hilton, Pamela Anderson and Kate Hudson etc.
People of every class and level can readily get these because their price is of every range.
And reproductions may perhaps appearance just like terrific.

my webpage; プラダ バッグ

2:04 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home